Identification points are listed only where two independent sources agree. Last reviewed 3 Nov 2026.
Buy a copy: eBay
No sales recorded yet
We value a printing from verified sales of that exact printing, and none of the first impression has come to auction in our records so far. The chart and the value by condition appear here as soon as one does.
Pro members with this book on their wantlist are emailed when it sells under their price.
Published by John Murray in London in October 1917 (Wikipedia gives 22 October); George H. Doran issued the American edition in New York the same month, so a Doran imprint means the US book. The British first is an octavo in red cloth lettered in gilt; dealers commonly report a faded or sunned spine and dulled gilt. The title page carries the John Murray imprint and the date 1917.
Read the full guide to John Murray first editions, decade by decade, and check your copy's copyright page against it. Our number line decoder reads the printing from the row of numbers.
We have not yet confirmed the issue points that tell this first impression from later ones. Until we do, compare your copy's title page and copyright page with the publisher, place and year above: any later printing or edition statement means it is not this one.
Know the points? Tell us. We publish them, with credit, once a second source agrees.
John Murray, London, in 1917, in hardback.
Points of issue are listed only where at least two independent sources agree. Last reviewed 3 November 2026. Reviewed by Harriet Ellis; read how we check facts.
The Sherlock Holmes first editions are nine London books from 1887 to 1927: A Study in Scarlet in Beeton's Christmas …
Read the guide →7 min readTo identify a first edition, check that your copy is the first printing of the first edition. Read the copyright …
Read the guide →6 min readBook condition grading uses a six-step trade scale: Fine, Near Fine, Very Good, Good, Fair and Poor. Collectors grade the …
Read the guide →