Thomas the Tank Engine, the second book in the Railway Series, was first published by Edmund Ward in 1946. Some catalogues give 1945, but that is the date of the first book in the series, The Three Railway Engines.
The quickest check is the pictures. The first edition was illustrated by Reginald Payne, who was not credited in the book. In 1950 C. Reginald Dalby redrew the illustrations for a new edition, and Dalby's pictures are the ones most people know. If your copy has Dalby's illustrations, it is from 1950 or later.
What to check:
- Date: Edmund Ward, 1946.
- Illustrations: Reginald Payne's original pictures, uncredited.
- Impression: later impressions are dated on the book, so check for a later impression statement before paying a first edition price.
Dealers describe the boards of early copies in different colours, and the board colour may separate the first printing from later ones, but we have not yet been able to confirm the details.
Early Railway Series books were small, cheap and read by children, so most surviving copies are worn. A first edition in its jacket, with clean boards and no scribbling, is genuinely scarce.
Sources: Wikipedia, Jonkers, John Atkinson Books, the Story Museum and sodor-island.com.